Gary proposed to me on our first cruise in October 2014. He asked me to just take a walk with him while we left his mom and his sister with all of our friends we met on the cruise. He literally took me all over the boat inside, outside, up stairs and down. Until finally we made our way back to the front of the boat. As we are looking out over the bow at this huge bright blue sunny sky and the water ahead of us he tells me to look out into the water he thought he saw something. When I was telling him " Babe your just seeing things I see nothing" I turned and he was down on one knee smiling. I didnt know what to say so I grabed him and the ring and hugged him, he wispers in my ear "sooooo are you saying yes?!". Well of course I would say yes! As I am hugging him and crying, all I hear is everyone we had left to go on our looooong walk was on the top deck above us screaming and cheering for us!